Professor Dr. Ali Shaker Abdul Qadir from the College of Law, University of Karbala, participated in the discussion committee for a master’s thesis in civil law, entitled (The Permanence of Text in Civil Law, a Comparative Study), which took place in the hall of the late Professor Dr. Abbas Al-Husseini, as a member and supervisor, and he praised the Scientific observations kindly made by the members of the discussion committee and urging the researcher to take them into account